Open Source Wins Slowly on My Mac

Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.

-Margaret Mead

For awhile now, I have been using the open source libgaim-based Adium alongside Defaultware’s shareware Proteus. While both offer connectivity to all the major instant messaging services, it is clear that Adium has won out on my desktop–and not just because it is free. In fact, there are a number of instances where freeware outstripped commercial/shareware offerings and open source has outstripped proprietary systems, and not for ideological reasons–but because the features, functionality and, yes, robustness has proved superior in my book to commercial alternatives. Perhaps this is a microcosm of how the “revolution” will look: a slow, steady progression, desktop by desktop, with programs like Firefox and Audacity leading the snail’s pace “charge”.

Liked this? Receive new ones in your inbox.

(You can unsubscribe any time.)


  • http://josherickson Josh Erickson

    Your quote up top there reminded me of this one.

    β€œIt does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate, tireless minority keen to set brushfires in people’s minds.” –Samuel Adams

  • Robert

    Thanks, Josh. I wonder if the open source community’s ability to remain “tireless” is directly proportional to its ability to remain “irate.” Interestingly enough, this recent survey:

    http://www.computereconomics.com/article.cfm?id=1043

    seems to indicate people are much more irate about being tied to a single vendor or proprietary approaches than they are about paying for software or even issues of security. So, I wonder as OSS continues to prove itself a viable alternative and commercial vendors adopt more open standards if we are going to ever reach a point where there are no more brushfires to light, where the fuss and hype finally dies down and people stop thinking about OSS as “free” software and start thinking about it as open, standards-compliant, flexible software that happens to be available for free along with the source code.

  • http://www.knobtweakers.net/ Eric

    Perhaps Audacity isn’t the best example. IMO, Linux is a viable alternative to windows as a server OS, but Audacity is far from a viable alternative to SoundForge for professional use.

    Compare Audacity to SoundForge, or WaveLab, and it comes out the clear loser of the bunch on everything but the price tag.

    Likewise, compare the Gimp to Photoshop, and Photoshop is the clear winner for most applications. In some arenas, open-source software clearly competes well, but closed-source software is still putting up a good fight in many cases.

    My favorite OSS products are FireFox and OpenOffice. =)

  • Robert

    Well, Eric, my reasons for liking Audacity don’t have to do with features in this case. It is simple and intuitive, and does the job for basic editing and recording. Sometimes fewer knobs are actually better, though I’m sure at some point I would want SoundForge or ProTools. But right now, Audacity does few things and does them well.